Updated November 14, 2024
Each quarter Saving For College analyzes the investment returns for thousands of 529 portfolios and ranks the 529 savings plans based on the overall performance of age-based and target-year portfolios offered by each plan.
The plans listed below are ones that consumers can enroll in directly. Premium subscribers can also access performance rankings for plans sold through brokers and RIAs (fee-based financial planners).
Here are our 529 performance rankings (data as of September 30, 2024).
1
2
2
4
State: West Virginia
Average return: 7.07%
5
6
State: Nebraska
Average return: 6.71%
7
State: Louisiana
Average return: 6.54%
8
State: Colorado
Average return: 6.51%
9
State: Kansas
Average return: 6.45%
10
State: West Virginia
Average return: 6.44%
In producing our age-based performance rankings, we analyze one-year, three-year, five-year and ten-year investment performance of all age-based or target-year portfolios offered by a 529 plan at each age band from 0 to 19+. We then calculate a hypothetical average annual return for all ages within each plan, and use this to rank the plans from best to worst performing. Please view our methodology for more details.
You should always review the portfolios offered by a plan and understand what is included before making an investment decision. Some portfolios are more aggressive than others, i.e., they include more equity, which may provide greater returns but greater risk as well. Be sure that you are comfortable with the risk level of your portfolios.
The ten-year performance ranking provides the best measure of long-term investment performance. However, note that many plans have introduced age-based portfolios recently, and do not yet have ten years' worth of performance history. Reviewing rankings from other time periods will allow you to see and compare the performance of a greater number of plans.
529 plans offer thousands of investment portfolios which can vary greatly in their composition. Comparing 529 plans based on investment performance is therefore no easy task and requires a special methodology. Saving For College has developed a proprietary enrollment-based methodology for ranking plans based on historical performance to assist college savers in comparing 529 plans.
1
We identify all enrollment-based portfolios from each 529 plan. These are dynamic portfolios designed to shift to more conservative asset allocations over time as the account beneficiary approaches college age. There are two types: age-based portfolios, in which the investor chooses the portfolio closest to the beneficiary’s current age; target-year portfolios, in which the investor chooses the portfolio closest to the expected year of college enrollment.
2
We then compare the historical performance of each of the selected portfolios within a given age band from 0 to 19+, over the past one-year, three-year, five-year and ten-year investment periods. There are separate comparisons for direct-sold and advisor-sold plans.
3
Finally, we calculate a hypothetical average annual return for each plan’s enrollment-based portfolios along a glide path from 0 to 19+, and rank the plans from highest to lowest return.
For a more in-depth explanation of our methodology, please read our white paper.
See the one-year direct-sold, three-year direct-sold, five-year direct-sold, ten-year direct-sold rankings.
Premium subscribers have access to performance rankings for advisor-sold 529 plans for the one-year, three-year, five-year and ten-year investment periods. In addition, subscribers can easily look up the historical performance for every 529 portfolio in every available share class by using our Fee and Performance Lookup Tool.